← Back to Blog

How to Avoid Overpaying for a Business in Australia

Nigel Gordon·
module-4valuationEBITDAbusiness-acquisitionAustralia

Overpaying for a business in Australia means paying more than the business's normalised earnings justify relative to comparable transactions in that industry. It doesn't always feel like overpaying at the time — sellers are good at explaining why their business is special, and brokers have no particular incentive to correct them. The result is that buyers either pay too much upfront, or they discover problems in due diligence and don't know how to adjust the price.

This guide covers the practical mechanics: what drives businesses to be overpriced, how to check whether the numbers actually add up, and what to do when you find the gap.

Why Businesses Get Overpriced in Australia

The short answer: because sellers anchor to a number they want rather than a number the market supports.

Australian small business owners typically spend years building something, and they calculate what they'd need to retire comfortably, then work backwards to arrive at an asking price. That's not valuation — it's retirement planning disguised as a for-sale listing.

Brokers are part of this. A business broker's commission is a percentage of the sale price, so there's a structural incentive to list high. Brokers will tell you they price businesses to sell, not to sit — and the good ones do. But plenty of listings sit for 12 months at prices that make no sense because no one wants to have the hard conversation with the vendor.

The practical rule: if a business has been listed for more than six months without an accepted offer, the price is wrong. That's not a sign of a unique asset — it's a sign of a vendor who hasn't accepted reality yet.

Industry Multiples: What's Normal for Trades Businesses

Overpaying is relative to something. That something is the EBITDA multiple — how many times the business's normalised annual earnings you're paying.

For trades businesses in Australia at the sub-$1 million enterprise value level, the typical range runs from 2x to 4x EBITDA. The position within that range depends on a few factors:

  • Recurring revenue and contracts. A plumbing business with commercial maintenance contracts will command more than one that does residential one-off callouts. Predictable revenue is worth more.
  • Owner dependency. A business where the owner does most of the technical work and holds all the customer relationships is worth less than one where the work runs without them. The buyer is essentially buying a job in the first case.
  • Management depth. Does the business have a lead supervisor or team leader who would stay? Or does everything flow through the owner?
  • Revenue concentration. If one customer represents more than 20% of revenue, that's a risk premium — the buyer should pay less, not more.
  • Growth trajectory. A business that has grown consistently over three years is more valuable than one with flat or declining revenue.

If someone is asking you to pay 5x or 6x EBITDA for a working-owner trades business in Melbourne or Brisbane, you should ask very pointed questions about why.

This is covered in depth in Module 4 of the Playbook. For a quick reference to where your target business should sit, the industry multiples cheat sheet lists typical ranges across 20-plus trade categories.

Where the Game Gets Played: EBITDA Add-Backs

The seller gives you financials showing the business made $150,000 profit last year. The broker says the EBITDA is actually $320,000 once you normalise for add-backs. You're being asked to buy at 3x that normalised figure.

This is where most buyers either overpay or get confused.

EBITDA add-backs are legitimate adjustments to reported profit — things the current owner runs through the business that a new owner wouldn't. The owner's salary above market rate. The wife's wage for work she doesn't actually do. The car lease that's personal use. The insurance policy for the owner's lake house.

Done properly, adding these back gives you a cleaner picture of what the business could earn under your ownership.

The problem is that sellers — particularly accountants working for sellers — get creative. Add-backs I've seen that were questionable or outright fiction:

  • "Owner's personal development" expense of $40,000 (golf club membership and three overseas conferences)
  • One-off "legal fees" that appeared in three consecutive years at similar amounts
  • Staff costs attributed to a redundant role that is immediately re-hired post-sale
  • Equipment purchases capitalised rather than expensed specifically in the sale-year financials

The rule here: every add-back needs a document behind it. If the broker says "trust us, that's add-backable", the right response is "great, show me the invoice and explain why it won't recur."

Normalising EBITDA is a skill, not a formula. You're trying to get to what the business will earn in your hands — not what it theoretically earned if you strip out everything convenient.

The EBITDA add-backs verification checklist gives you a structured way to work through each adjustment with the seller's accountant.

The Working Capital Trap

Most buyers focus on the purchase price and don't think enough about what they're inheriting in terms of working capital — the cash, receivables, and inventory needed to keep the business running day to day.

Here's how the trap works. A seller knows settlement is coming in 90 days. They stop chasing debtors aggressively, they run down stock, and they delay paying creditors. On settlement day, the business has a lower receivables balance and higher creditor balance than normal. The buyer hands over the agreed price and immediately discovers they need to inject an extra $60,000 to keep the business solvent.

Working capital adjustments in the sale agreement are supposed to prevent this — you agree on a normalised working capital target, and if the actual balance at settlement differs, the price adjusts. The problem is that buyers often don't negotiate this clause hard enough, or don't understand what a "normalised" figure actually looks like for this business.

Get 12 months of monthly balance sheets and calculate average receivable days and creditor days. That's your baseline. Any significant divergence at settlement is a price adjustment.

Hidden Costs That Inflate the Real Price

Beyond working capital, a few categories of hidden cost routinely turn an apparently fair price into an overpayment:

Plant and equipment condition. A trades business with a fleet of vehicles and equipment might look profitable on the numbers — but if two of the three vans need replacing within six months, that's $80,000 in unplanned capex. Always get an independent assessment of major equipment as part of due diligence.

Employee entitlements. Long-serving employees carry accrued annual leave and long service leave. In a vendor's financials, these are often understated or not reflected as a liability. The buyer assumes these on settlement. A workforce of eight tradespeople who've been there eight to ten years each can represent $150,000-plus in inherited entitlements.

WHS and regulatory compliance. A roofing business or electrical contractor with deferred maintenance on safety compliance isn't just a legal risk — it's a remediation cost the buyer has to absorb.

I saw a buyer pay a fair multiple for a Brisbane pest control business last year, only to discover post-settlement that three of the operator's licences had lapsed and needed to be renewed through a process that took four months and prevented the business from taking on new commercial contracts. The price was right on the numbers; it was wrong once you factored in the opportunity cost of frozen revenue.

When to Get an Independent Valuation

If you're buying a business for $500,000 or more, spending $4,000-$8,000 on an independent business valuation is not optional — it's insurance.

An independent business valuer will give you a formal report that either confirms the asking price sits within a defensible range, or flags that it doesn't. More importantly, the process of commissioning it forces you to formalise your assumptions — what growth rate are you assuming, what normalised earnings are you using, what multiple are you applying.

A quality of earnings report goes further, commissioned from an accountant to independently verify the earnings quality. This is standard practice in mid-market acquisitions and worth considering for any deal above $750,000 where the seller's financials haven't been audited.

Even without a formal report, bringing your own accountant in to review the vendor's numbers — separately from the vendor's accountant — is a non-negotiable step. The seller's accountant is not working for you, regardless of how helpful they seem.

What to Do When You Think the Price Is Wrong

You've done your analysis and the numbers don't stack up. The business is being offered at 4.5x what you think is the real normalised EBITDA, not 3x. What now?

Option 1: Renegotiate with evidence. Don't just say "I think it's too high". Come in with a specific counter-offer and a clear explanation of your methodology — your normalised EBITDA number, your comparable multiple, your price. Sellers can argue with feelings; they find it harder to argue with a spreadsheet. Renegotiating the price after due diligence covers the mechanics of doing this without blowing up the deal.

Option 2: Restructure the terms. If the seller won't move on price, you might move on structure. Vendor finance where the seller takes back 20% of the purchase price at a deferred payment means you're only exposing your own cash to 80% of the price risk. An earn-out clause where a portion of the price is contingent on the business hitting certain revenue targets post-settlement aligns the seller's interest with yours.

Option 3: Walk away. Sometimes the numbers don't work and no structuring fixes them. Walking away from a deal you spent three months on is genuinely difficult (the sunk cost feels enormous), but it's better than the alternative. Overpaying for a business creates a structural problem — you've spent more on the asset than it will comfortably service from its own cash flows, which means you're working primarily to service debt rather than build equity.

The offer price calculation framework helps you work through the right number before you make an offer, so you don't end up negotiating against yourself.

FAQ

How do I know if a business is overpriced?

Compare the asking price to 2-4x the business's normalised EBITDA for a trades business, or 2-3x for a higher-risk working-owner operation. If the seller's add-backs look inflated, the real multiple is higher than advertised.

What is a fair EBITDA multiple for a small business in Australia?

For most blue-collar service businesses with revenue under $2 million, 2-4x normalised EBITDA is typical. Businesses with strong recurring contracts, low owner dependency, and a management layer can sit at the top of that range or above.

Should I get an independent valuation when buying a business?

For any acquisition above $400,000-$500,000, yes. The cost of an independent valuation report (typically $4,000-$8,000) is small relative to the risk of overpaying by $50,000-$100,000 on the purchase price.

Can I renegotiate after signing the heads of agreement?

You can, but it requires a genuine reason tied to something found in due diligence — a material add-back that doesn't hold up, undisclosed liabilities, equipment in worse condition than represented. Renegotiating purely because you've changed your mind will damage the deal and likely kill it.

What is the biggest overpaying trap for first-time buyers?

Accepting the seller's EBITDA number without independently verifying each add-back. The difference between what the seller calls normalised EBITDA and what actually flows into your pocket as a new owner can be substantial.


Subscribe to The Leveraged Worker newsletter for weekly deal analysis, valuation case studies, and business acquisition frameworks written from the trenches, not the textbook.